• 1 Post
  • 8 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 24th, 2024

help-circle
  • The bigger question here and this I think is what subcontiously resonates with this this story is why do you even punish and I think there are three partly compeeding answers.

    • First because you want to avoid such thing from happening again

    • Secondly because you try to scare people from doing the same

    • Thirdly because you want fellons to reflect on there behavior and give them a path to redemption

    For the second goal I point at the fact that it happened although this sentence is possible.


  • Inderd I did. You started with:

    […] He traveled to murder a guy he never met before after stalking him online, carved words from a manifesto into bullet casings, engineered a 3D printable unregistered firearm, fled the scene of the crime with enough cash to live off of for years, and openly denies any wrongdoing by pleading innocent. He is absolutely likely to try it again, or perhaps worse, if released.

    If the death penalty exists, and honestly I don’t think it should, then it should apply fairly and treat all human life equally.

    This is why I mentioned possible jailtime in my previous comment as a lesser evil and made the point that your represented pov is a logical falacy as it is based on a non existing moral dilemma. So the only thing it represents is an argument of authority.



  • Just for the sake of argument. You say that because he killed and probably will kill again, death penalty is justifiable . By the same line of reasoning this should be valid as well for the judge, the attorney and every other person responsible for the final execution. You could even make the argument for the victim, as he killed people by actively rejecting proper medical care in multiple cases.